TTTTT H H EEEEE
T H H E
T HHHHH EEEEE
T H H E
T H H EEEEE
PPPP OOOO RRRR TTTTT L A N N DDDD I A N N TM
P P O O R R T L A A NN N D D I A A NN N
PPPP O O RRRR T L AAAAA N N N D D I AAAAA N N N
P O O R R T L A A N NN D D I A A N NN
P OOOO R R T LLLLL A A N N DDDD I A A N N
*****************************************************************
The Portlandian, the Internet's premier source of Tonya News
September 30, 2004 Edition - SPECIAL DOUBLE ISSUE
(C) 2004 Portland Ice Skating Society
http://www.geocities.com/portice
*****************************************************************
It's been a long time since our last issue, and in that time
there's been alot happening to Tonya, particularly in her boxing
career, which has been on a "Rocky" road in all the wrong senses
of the word. So this issue we've decided to make a special bumper
length edition to catch up with all the news.
ABSURDITY IN ALBERTA
On Friday the 25th of June, Tonya made her international boxing
debut in a four-round match against 22-year-old Edmonton,
Alberta nursing student Amy Johnson. Tonya's fight was the last
on the undercard before the WBC Continental Americas super
bantamweight title fight June 25 at the Shaw Conference Centre in
Edmonton.
Sadly, the result did not go the way Tonyaphiles would have
hoped, with the fight being stopped 1:03 into the third round and
Johnson being awarded a technical knockout against Tonya.
"You name it, she threw it," a weary Tonya said. "She threw a lot
more than I anticipated and, you know, it was her night." "She
got the one opportunity to fight Tonya Harding and, of course,
that gives you that extra energy and everything else. Let her
have that 15 minutes of fame."
"It's been almost a complete year since I fought and I went out
and I've shown that I do have some skills," said Tonya. "I just
need some more bouts to get under my belt." Tonya did, however,
manage to knock Johnson down at one stage. Tonya sustained a
blackened left eye and swollen nose for her efforts.
"This is my first knockout," said Johnson, whose record now
stands at 2-0-1. "I felt so much stronger than she was. I just
felt like going in, like it's my town, my time to shine."
But this result has been marred by accusations of cheating and
incompetent judging. Who says boxing isn't like figure skating?
Now, regular followers of Tonya news will know that accusations
of dirty play and bad sportsmanship in any sports event involving
Tonya are nothing new - but this time there's a twist: it's
Tonya's opponent who's being accused of being the cheat! Tonya's
manager Paul Brown filed a formal complaint with the Edmonton
Boxing and Wrestling Commission over the referee's handling of
the fight and the Commission held a hearing on September 1.
The basis for the complaint was the referee's handling of
Johnson's knockdown of Tonya in the third round. Brown alleges
several irregularities, such as Johnson being given extra time
after the standing-eight count finished to get ready, and that
Johnson did several things that indicated she wanted to give up,
such as waving her arms and spitting out her mouthguard. Her
trainer also stepped onto the side of the ring, which is used as
a signal to indicate the fight should be stopped. Also of concern
is that Johnson appeared to be engaging in the illegal practice
of "lacing" - rubbing her gloves into Tonya's face - on several
occasions.
And Brown seems to have got some support from a surprising
corner: Sue "Tiger Lily" Fox, of WBAN, the main women's boxing
website, endorses Brown's view. As Fox was originally a skeptic
about Tonya's boxing plans she can hardly be seen as someone
biased in Tonya's favor. The WBAN site has video supplied by
Brown of several sections of the fight and much of the text of
his complaint:
http://womenboxing.com/news072804hardingprotest.htm
http://womenboxing.com/news073004poll.htm
http://womenboxing.com/news081104resultsofhardingpoll%20.htm
The site also has video of part of the second round of the fight
where Tonya's knockdown of Johnson occurred. If you don't have a
broadband connection the best way to view this is to right-click
and save one of the "cable" versions to your hard disk and run it
from there. Although it will take about 15 minutes to download,
the results will be much clearer than trying to view the dial-up
version provided. In addition to the issue of the knockout,
notice how Johnson apparently spends several seconds holding onto
Tonya and pushing her gloves into Tonya's face, which seems to
support Brown's claim that she was engaging in the practice of
"lacing" that he refers to in his complaint.
Firstly, Johnson waves her arms at the ref., which could be taken
as indicating she wants to give up. Johnson has her mouthpiece in
when she waves to the ref, so clearly she can't be saying
anything at that stage, so it's not clear what the arm-waving
means. The ref would have been quite entitled to assume she was
conceding. She then spits it out as she walks away from him to
her corner. He is actually counting with his fingers as well and
by the time he finishes Johnson is still not ready, she is about
to say something to the guy in her corner. It's almost as if she
doesn't realize the count has actually finished at this point, or
just doesn't understand the rules. She then turns around and has
a discussion with the ref, replaces the mouthguard and is then
allowed to continue. In fact the fight doesn't resume until
around 8 seconds AFTER the standing-8 count finishes, so Johnson
effectively had 16 seconds - double the time she was supposed to
be allowed - to regain her composure and start fighting again.
Whatever the reason for the delay, she should have been
disqualified as she was clearly not ready to resume fighting when
the referee finished his count.
Despite this clear evidence, for reasons that have not so far
become public, the EBWC then refused Brown's request for the
result to be ruled a no-contest. So it looks as if Tonya has once
gain been ripped off. Fortunately this may not be the end of the
matter, as Brown is keen to schedule a rematch, preferably in
Portland during early 2005, perhaps even at the same time as the
upcoming US Figure Skating Nationals that will be held in that
city when interest in Tonya will naturally resurface.
Here are some more articles about the fight:
http://www.oregonlive.com/sports/oregonian/index.ssf?/base/sports
/1086350681285980.xml
http://www.canoe.ca/Slam/Boxing/2004/06/17/503271.html
This article also discusses the complaint:
http://slam.canoe.ca/Slam/Boxing/2004/07/14/539447.html
MILLION DOLLAR PAYDAY FOR TONYA?
The actions of the referee in Edmonton and the Edmonton Boxing
and Wrestling Commission may have cost Tonya big bucks:
http://www.oregonlive.com/sports/oregonian/index.ssf?/base/sports
/108799239284500.xml
In an article in the Oregonian the same Canadian promoter who
arranged the Johnson fight, Wayne Barry, was quoted as saying
that a group of Edmonton businessmen are behind a deal that would
see Tonya get a guaranteed $600,000 plus a share of the gate
takings and pay-per-view revenues in a fight that would have
taken place sometime next February against Jelana Mrdjenovich, a
Canadian fighter of Serbian extraction. "I would anticipate she
would make a million and a half," Barry said. If so, it would be
the biggest payout ever for women's boxing, where prize money is
puny compared to men's boxing, even for well known fighters such
as Laila Ali and Christy Martin. It would also at last bring
Tonya some financial stability and a long overdue compensation
for her hard work that she was robbed of by the skating
community.
Mrdjenovich, aged 22, fought on the undercard of the Johnson
bout. With a 5-0 record with four knockouts she is well known in
Canada and backers expect that combining her with the notorious
Tonya would bring alot of interest.
The Mrdjenovich fight was, however, contingent on Tonya winning
her four-round fight against Johnson. With Tonya's loss, the deal
is now up in the air and may not go ahead.
CONFUSION IN CALIFORNIA
Edmonton wasn't the only Tonya event recently to end in
controversy. When we last reported, Tonya was in Oakland,
California, preparing for a fight against Tracy Carlton. Tonya
was originally supposed to fight Blanca Hilder but pulled out
when it was discovered that Hilder was nowhere near as
inexperienced as she had been made out to be:
"They tried to pull a fast one on us with Hilder," Tonya's
trainer Paul Brown says, "They said it was her pro debut. She'd
never fought before, but we found out she was a West Coast
kickboxing champion with a 15-2 record." As it turned out, Tonya
would not fight that day at all, with the fight eventually being
between Hilder and Carlton in front of a 3000 strong crowd.
Needless to say the promoters have tried to make it look like
Tonya's fault, issuing a nasty press release about how Tonya had
pulled out of two previous fights. They fail to mention, of
course, that the first pullout was on the advice of her doctors
and the second on the advice of her lawyers - nothing that Tonya
instigated. Nor do they admit their perfidy in trying to con
Tonya into fighting someone with much more experience than they
make out (or the fact that their proposed "alternative", Carlton,
was a good 20 centimeters or 8 inches taller than Tonya which
would have made the match a total joke).
"If they were honest with us (about Hilder's amateur record), we
wouldn't have been in that situation," Brown said. "Tonya is in
the developmental stages."
Shortly afterwards the true reason for Tonya's refusal to fight
was revealed: the Associated Press reported that Tonya's trainer
Paul Brown received a telephoned death threat shortly before the
fight.
Despite the height difference, Tonya was quite happy to fight
Carlton until things got ugly. It appears that the trouble began
around the time of the weigh-in at the Hilton Hotel on Friday
before the California Boxing Commission. Brown says that he and
Tonya were in the hotel bar when some of Carlton's people began
threatening Tonya and trying to cause problems, with Tonya being
subjected to threats and racial slurs - stuff that goes way
beyond the usual "trash talking" that occurs in boxing.
"We went before the boxing commission like professionals," Brown
said, "but even before the paperwork was filled out, this girl
(Carlton, who is black) began making racial insults against
Tonya. It got so bad one of the commissioners jumped up and said,
'That's enough. If you continue this behavior, there will not be
a fight.' We were just not going to get caught up in a bunch of
drama".
Brown and Tonya then left the bar as a result. "I had to get her
out of there. It was almost like there was going to be a race
riot," Brown was quoted by the Portland Tribune as saying.
Shortly afterward, he says, he received a call on his cell phone
from a man saying "If Tonya doesn't fight, I'll kill you."
"I'm a mortician by trade," Brown said. "I treat death with the
utmost respect. I don't play when it comes to death and death
threats."
Brown says the promoters then "offered us $15,000 to stay and
fight. We walked away from $24,000. You can't spend it if you're
dead." Brown and Tonya then returned to Portland. A complaint was
filed with the Oakland Police.
It is, of course, not the first time Tonya has been forced to
withdraw from a competition because of a threat to her safety. In
November 1993 Tonya withdrew from a USFSA skating competition in
Portland after also receiving a threat.
The San Francisco Chronicle has a lengthy article and a photo of
Tonya with Blanca Hilder. It also debunks the idea that some are
floating that Tonya was just trying to get paid for nothing.
Tonya will in fact not get paid for the fight, and Brown has
promised that $2000 that was advanced will be returned. Tonya in
fact gets nothing out of this but alot of aggravation:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/c/a/2004/03/23/SP
GHS5PG2A1.DTL&type=printable
Another article is from the Contra Costa Times (reprinted in the
San Jose Mercury News):
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/sports/8259983.htm
TONYA ON "THE MAN SHOW"
Early in May Comedy Central aired the episode of "The Man Show"
that Tonya recorded back in March. In order to promote the show,
Tonya embarked on an ambitious media blitz that saw her doing
dozens of radio interviews over two days in late April involving
stations from across the entire country. In addition, a clip from
the match was broadcast on the "Tonite Show With Jay Leno" on NBC
in early May during an interview with one of the show's hosts.
Tonya fights three rounds with the show's host, Doug Stanhope. In
radio interviews Tonya gave the impression that lots of fun was
had by all.
Here are a couple of articles about Tonya's appearance that may
be of interest. The first is a general interview about Tonya's
new career:
http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page3/story?page=harding/040503
The second is an interview with Tonya and Doug Stanhope:
http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page3/story?page=tonyadoug/040503
Unfortunately one side effect of Tonya having to do this
promotional work was that she missed out on a scheduled session
with world renowned nutritionist Makie Shilstone in New Orleans.
TONYA MAKES A NAME FOR HERSELF
June also saw the publication of a lengthy and reasonably
positive article in the Washington Post about Tonya (and no, it's
not by Christine Brennan). The article was widely redistributed,
even turning up here in our hometown paper of "The Christchurch
Press":
http://msnbc.msn.com/id/5085404/
Much of the article covers Tonya's boxing and her life up until
now, territory that will be familiar to long-time Tonya
followers. But it is good to see her getting such significant and
favorable coverage in the mainstream media.
The article does, however, contain one contentious point: it
claims that the decline in popularity of the name "Tonya" itself
was caused by the Kerrigan scandal. In fact, the article's own
figures, drawn from US Social Security data, show that "Tonya"
was already on the decline well before the Kerrigan incident,
having dropped from 52nd in popularity in its heyday of the 1970s
to 571st in 1993. In 1996 it was 923rd and in 1998 it fell out of
the top 1000 names altogether.
A closer analysis of the data at the Social Security web site
shows that "Tonya" first appeared in the top 1000 in the 1950s
where it ranked as 434th. It then rose to 120th in the 60s,
peaked at 52nd in the 70's and dropped back to 166th in the 80s.
In the 90s, the earliest decade for which year by year data is
available, the decline continued:
1990 - 393
1991 - 447 - down 54 places
1992 - 477 - down 30 places
1993 - 571 - down 94 places
1994 - 621 - down 50 places
1995 - 773 - down 152 places
1996 - 921 - down 148 places
1997 - 923 - down 2 places
So although the Kerrigan incident probably did have an effect, it
was just the final nail in the coffin for a name that was already
out of fashion anyway and it's ridiculous to blame Tonya Harding
for the decline.
TEN YEARS OF HYPOCRISY
The end of June marked the tenth anniversary of one of the most
disgraceful events in the sport of figure skating - the shafting
of one of its top competitors on the basis of flimsy evidence,
most of it either circumstantial or based on the rantings of
liars and convicted criminals.
At the end of June 1994, the United States Figure Skating
Association over a period of two days held a nine-hour, closed-
door disciplinary hearing in Colorado Springs into the Harding-
Kerrigan incident, a hearing that in a unanimous decision ended
with a life ban being imposed upon Tonya Harding in relation to
USFSA-sanctioned events. In an attempt to alter history, the
five-member hearing panel also stripped Tonya of her 1994
Nationals title that she had won earlier that year. Tonya was not
present at the hearing, and did not appeal the findings, though
given the USFSA's long hostility towards her it probably would
have been a waste of time. The report prepared by the panel,
believed to run for several hundred pages, has never been
publicly released.
"By a preponderance of the evidence, the five members of the
panel concluded that she had prior knowledge and was involved
prior to the incident," hearing panel chairman William Hybl said
to the "Washington Post" afterwards in a telephone interview from
Colorado Springs. "This is based on civil standards, not criminal
standards." They found that Tonya's conduct "intentionally
undermines the concept of sportsmanship and fair play embodied in
the USFSA bylaws and rules and amateur sportsmanship in general".
"Ms. Harding's actions as they related to the assault on Nancy
Kerrigan evidence a clear disregard for fairness, good
sportsmanship and ethical behavior," the panel added. The hearing
went ahead despite the fact that Tonya had resigned from the
USFSA several months earlier as the USFSA wanted to "finalize"
Tonya's status, Hybl said. "We want there to be no doubt".
Tonya's attorney, Robert Weaver, issued a statement on her behalf
saying "She categorically denies the statements of Jeff Gillooly
and others relied upon by the hearing panel that she had any
prior knowledge of or participated in the assault on Nancy
Kerrigan".
The effects of the ban have gone way beyond merely depriving
Tonya of a chance to participate in USFSA events. It also
prohibits her from skating as a pro in events that contain USFSA
skaters and means she can no longer be a coach of record, which
further shuts off her vocational options in skating. Furthermore,
many pro skaters have been afraid to skate with Tonya because of
a perception, whether real or not, that they will be subjected to
similar unofficial blacklisting by the USFSA. As a result, Tonya
has since skated in only one competition, a one-off event for
ESPN in Huntington, West Virginia, in October 1999 where she came
second. With such limited options Tonya has been forced to turn
to a variety of other ways of making a living, culminating
recently in her boxing career.
That such a harsh punishment was imposed is galling, given the
thinness of the case against Tonya, but it is especially
hypocritical in view of the sport's reaction to other much worse
offenses where there is much stronger evidence. In particular,
the slap-on-the-wrist punishments handed out to cheating judges,
who often return to adjudicate over high-level contests after
token bans of only two or three years, or even less. We've seen
this at Nagano and at Salt Lake City, and despite calls for
reform from fans it is likely to continue, given the ISU's
predilection for secrecy. The gutlessness of the USFSA, one of
the few skating organizations with enough power to stand up to
the ISU and force it to come down hard on cheating judges is
astounding and displays a blatant double standard. Who has caused
more damage to skating - Tonya, who at worst covered up, under
duress, a crime committed by others that attempted to
disadvantage only a single competitor, or those who repeatedly
try to rig entire contests - and do so over and over again? Or
those in the ISU and its affiliates who turn a blind eye or even
actively try to cover up such cheating with secret scoring
systems and by punishing whistleblowers who dare to speak out?
It's time to stop the hypocrisy and let Tonya skate again.
TONYA THE MUSE - PORTLAND SONGWRITER "OUTS" HIMSELF AS A
TONYAPHILE, AND TONYA BECOMES FASHIONABLE
A "muse" is a figure in Greek classical mythology that inspires
creativity in artistic types. And we've had two examples just
recently of Tonya being the inspiration for creative endeavors.
Richard Moore is one of Portland's hardest working actors - yet
most people wouldn't recognize him if he walked past them in a
supermarket.
Moore is a "voice talent" - one of those people who make a living
doing voiceovers for radio and TV commercials. He's also a
recording engineer and a songwriter who has recorded several
albums. His story is told in a recent article in the Portland
Tribune:
http://www.portlandtribune.com/archview.cgi?id=24601
Most importantly for us, he's also a Tonyaphile. His latest
album, "What Goes Around", features a song about our favorite
skater turned boxer. Entitled simply "Tonya", the song is a
heartfelt piece about the cruel treatment Tonya received in her
home town. You can hear a two-minute extract from it at:
http://mp3.cdbaby.com/r/rmoore-09.mp3
You can also visit Richard Moore's web site at
http://www.mooredick.com. And you can order the CD at:
http://www.cdbaby.com
The second example is a British fashion designer, Peter Jensen,
who chose to show off his spring/summer 2005 collection at an ice
rink during London's recent Fashion Week promotion. The
collection, which bears something of a resemblance to figure-
skating costumes, was modeled by skaters leaping and gliding
around the rink rather than on a catwalk in what has to be a
relatively unconventional method of fashion display.
In an article in The Independent newspaper Jensen specifically
cites Tonya as the inspiration for the collection. But then
Jensen has a history of being inspired by unlikely public
figures: since he graduated from Central Saint Martins art
college in 1999, some of his previous collections have been
dedicated to Gertrude Stein, Cindy Sherman and Russian gymnast
Olga Korbut.
http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/this_britain/story.jsp?story=564
745
CLEANUP, WHAT CLEANUP? THEY'RE STILL AT IT
With the Athens Olympics in the news recently, we thought it was
an opportune time to take a look at what progress the IOC has
made since Salt Lake in cleaning up its act. And the answer is
definitely "nice try, but no cigar".
In a little-reported move virtually on the eve of the Games
commencing, the IOC has taken action against two of its sleaziest
members: Mohamad "Bob" Hasan, the crooked rainforest logger from
Indonesia and Ivan Slavkov, the son-in-law of former Bulgarian
dictator Todor Zhivkov, who has been charged with embezzling
Olympic funds and illegal arms trading. Hasan was suspended by
the IOC in May 2001 but his expulsion was postponed while his
conviction for a forest mapping swindle was reviewed by the
courts. He served four years of a six year sentence and is now
free on parole. It also comes two months after the suspension of
Dr. Un-Yong Kim of Korea after his conviction on bribery charges.
It's quite a comedown for Kim, who was at one stage seen as a
possible successor to Samaranch, but should be no surprise as he
was one of the biggest players in the SLC scandal, for which he
received a "serious warning". Oh, how the mighty have fallen.
This is quite a change from 2000 when the IOC threw a hissy fit
at Hasan being refused leave from jail to attend the Sydney
Olympics. They also seem to be at last getting serious about
clamping down on drugs, with 24 dopers - double the previous
highest number, set at Los Angeles in 1984 - being caught at
Athens. Could it be that change is finally happening in the IOC?
Well, maybe, but still not enough. A one-year undercover
investigation by the BBC's "Panorama" team indicates that some
members are still soliciting bribes, just a bit more carefully
than before. The truckloads of gifts and expensive junkets may be
gone, but the wads of dirty cash in envelopes are still there.
Often the money is laundered through several intermediaries in
order to disguise what's really going on.
In a new documentary which aired in Britain earlier last month,
"Buying the Games", "Panorama" found that "fixers" are still
offering to sell the votes of some IOC members to bidding cities
for the right price. Posing as agents for a group of London
businessmen eager to see that city get the Games, BBC reporters
met with four of these "agents". Most disturbingly, one of these
fixers claims that approximately 70% of those who took bribes
over Salt Lake are still in the IOC, and even supplied a list of
35 IOC members they claim are open to corruption. These claims
are in line with those by Max Wheeler, a lawyer who worked on the
Salt Lake case, who says in the documentary "we had gone through
and made a list of IOC members that we could prove had accepted
gifts or benefits, and we figured it was something like 85% of
the total membership of the IOC had engaged in at least one
violation during our bid".
"Panorama" also uncovered new evidence about Stockholm's
unsuccessful bid for the 2004 Games. Mats Ekman, a Swedish
researcher, has compiled a database of tens of thousands of
entries relating to the bid and concludes that Stockholm was just
as dirty as Salt Lake City. "The Swedish bid committee afterwards
(were) denying the whole time, denying, denying, denying. 'We
didn't use an agent, we played a fair game.' They didn't. They
played an unfair game" says Ekman.
Ekman has discovered some very interesting banking transactions
made by the bid committee head two days before the final vote. At
11.10 that morning Olaf Stenhammer, the chairman of the Swedish
bid committee, withdrew 460,000 Krona from his personal bank
account and transferred it to another account where thirty
minutes later an associate withdrew the money in the form of nine
separate bank drafts possibly to avoid the attention of money
laundering authorities. These bank drafts were then changed into
$US50,000 in hundred dollar bills at several currency exchanges
across central Stockholm. Stenhammer claimed that the 50 grand
was for a family holiday and never left Sweden. Sweden's chief
state prosecutor investigated the Olympic bid and was sceptical
of Stenhammer's explanation. After all, why would you need to
change Swedish currency into US dollars if you're holidaying in
Sweden?
The BBC team's biggest catch, however, was Slavkov, who was
caught in the act of soliciting a bribe. This is the reason for
his suspension.
Further details can be found at:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/sport1/hi/other_sports/olympics_
2012/3938619.stm
A full transcript of the program can be found here:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/spl/hi/programmes/panorama/trans
cripts/buyingthegames.txt
We've updated our Olympic Hall of Shame table to reflect these
recent developments:
http://www.geocities.com/portice/ioc.htm
*****************************************************************
VISIT THESE GREAT TONYA WEB SITES:
PortIce - http://www.geocities.com/portice
David House - http://www.tonyaharding.org
Charlie Main - http://www.charliesweb.com/tonya/tonya.html
Puppetboy - http://www.puppetland.com/tonya/
Valerie Smith - http://www.olywa.net/radu/valerie/LilHam.html
Swan Lake - http://members.tripod.com/~TonyaHarding/index.html
Blades of Gold - http://members.tripod.com/tmhfan/index.html
*****************************************************************
Back to Portlandian index
Back to PortIce Home Page
This page hosted by
Get your own Free Home Page